Buying a Home:The Qur'an (2:276) says: " Allah has permitted trade and forbidden
usury," and in 2:278 reminds the Muslims: "O ye who believe,
keep your duty to Allah and relinquish what remains (due) from interest,
if you are believers."
Like any other human being, Muslims also need and desire a secure
dwelling for themselves and their families. Until recently, owning
a home was an unthinkable proposition for practicing Muslims because
this would involve taking out a mortgage and interest (or usury)
is prohibited by Islam. A mortgage is a long term loan, usually
for a person or family to purchase a house over a long period (eg:
30 years).
Over the past few years, some prominent scholars have allowed Muslims
living in Western countries to buy homes using a mortgage, on the
premise that this is the only way available, and that rent is a
long term waste of money.
These include, Yusuf Talal DeLorenzo, Yusuf Al Qaradawi, Mustafa
Al Zarqa, Mish`al Al Mubarak, and others.
Yusuf Talal DeLorenzo
Sharia Advisor to Dow Jones Islamic Index, has a reply on a question
about mortgages available at the
Muslim-Investor
web site.
Dr. Yusuf Al Qaradawi
The European Council for Fatwa and Research, chaired by Dr. Yusuf
Al Qaradawi, has issued this fatwa as part of its Final Statement
on 31 October 1999 for its Fourth Ordinary Session. You can view
the fatwa in English
here
and in Arabic here.
For the sake of completeness, Dr. Qaradawi's opinion has raised
some objections from other scholars, such as Dr. Mahmoud Al Tahan
and Jalal Aamer.
Please note that this mortgage fatwah is not allowed in all cases
or to all people. There are some restriction to consider. These
include that the person engaging in mortgage does not have other
assets (such as land or real estate) that could be sold and used
to buy a home, that it is his main residence, and not a second mortgage
(e.g. investment property). Please refer to the fatwa above for
details.
Despite the fatwahs that have been passed, many Muslims still do
not feel comfortable buying a home using a conventional secular
mortgage. Some Housing Cooperatives have started in Canada and the
USA to allow Muslims to buy houses in an interest-free way.
As a courtesy to members of the Muslim community, RICMA is providing
tools* and information to get a quick comparison of both the secular
and Islamic mortgage systems. Please realize that figures shown
may vary from actual expenses due to additional fees, insurance,
taxes, and/or unknown factors
.
| * |
Due to a limitation of resources to RICMA, the following comparison
may fail if the numbers entered require intensive computation.
If you get an error after pressing the 'Calculate' button, reduce
the loan term (number of months) and try again. |
| ** |
The formula used to calculate the Islamic numbers is based
on the Rent/Share Method and is described in detail at LaRiba.com. |
| *** |
The formula used to calculate the secular numbers is the default
mortgage
formula as used by mortgage calculators, banks, and other
financial institutions. |